At a poker game with Ray and Bad Larry, two CIA buddies, Stan reveals that he has never actually killed anyone and is therefore a "killing virgin." So Roger and the guys set out to help Stan land his first hit. Stan passes on several candidates including Randy, a pedophile that announces he just moved into the neighborhood.
Meanwhile, Steve and his friends are befriended by Randy who has immediately sought to resume his old ways by kidnapping Steve and his friends. When Stan and his friends find out Steve has been taken by pedophile Randy to his secret hideout behind the waterfall at Wet, Young & Wild water park, they rush in to save the boys. When Randy brags that he'll get off due to his mother's money and a good lawyer, Stan tries to shoot Randy and ends up killing Bad Larry getting his very first kill.