Donny Forfeit is the backup quarterback for The Langley Falls Bazooka Sharks.

When Steve is horrified that star quarterback Juan 'Johnny Concussion' Consuelo could be seriously hurt in a Bazooka Sharks championship game in "Bazooka Steve", he tricks him into leaving the stadium, forcing the Sharks to put in Donny who promptly forfeits the game. With no other option, a later headline notes that Donny was given a contract extension.